Coalition Goes Full Boonta On Q&A, Abbott Calls It A “Lefty Lynch Mob”

Credit where it’s due, when they smell blood they certainly don’t waste any time circling the wound.

The Coalition has been on the front foot all day in attacking the ABC‘s flagship Rancor pit, Q&A. Following the programme’s decision to give airtime to Zaky Mallah – a man once charged with plotting a terrorist attack back in 2003 – during which he sparked controversy for comments that many media outlets (including this one) erroneously reported as an urge for young Australians to join the Islamic State.
What Mallah actually said was far from an urge, and was merely a comment riffing on the idea that potential laws and conduct from the Liberal Party provide the conditions and impetus for young Muslim men who feel oppressed or disenfranchised to leave and go to Syria and join the IS.
“The Liberals have just justified to many Australian Muslims in the community tonight to leave and go to Syria and join ISIL because of ministers like him.”
A boneheaded comment, to be sure, and one definitely worthy of apology from the ABC – which Tony Jones summarily did. But not an actual urge in the slightest.
The ABC went ahead and admitted allowing Mallah into the audience was an error in judgment, but stressed the unpredictability of live TV broadcasting. Aunty’s TV Director Richard Finlayson issued a statement earlier today.

“In attempting to explore important issues about the rights of citizens and the role of the Government in fighting terrorism, the Q&A program made an error in judgement in allowing Zaky Mallah to join the audience and ask a question.”

“Mr Mallah has been interviewed by the Australian media on a number of occasions. The environment of a live television broadcast, however, meant it would not be possible for editorial review of the comments he might make prior to broadcast, particularly if he engaged in debate beyond his prepared question.

Tony Jones correctly and immediately ruled a statement made by Mr Mallah as out of order.”


“Q&A will continue to raise issues that are provocative and controversial. There is always risk in undertaking live television. That is the nature of the Q&A program since it first aired in 2008.

As has been the case in the past on Q&A, circumstances will happen that are not anticipated. The critical question is whether risks could have been managed and the right editorial judgments made in advance.”


“The circumstances of Mr Mallah’s appearance will be reviewed by the ABC.”
Nevertheless, the Coalition has been pressing down harder with the proverbial foot on the throat of the programme – and the National Broadcaster writ large – for the duration of today, with comments from the Backbench being particularly nasty and vitriolic.
Alex Hawke – the Federal member for Mitchell – stated that “It’s almost as if the ABC is engaged in some form of sedition.” He added, “They have utterly no regard for what they are doing on this show and the people who will suffer the most is the moderate Islamic community in Australia.”

Meanwhile Craig Kelly, the Federal member for Hughes, went a step further into borderline farcical territory with the insinuation that Mallah was deliberately planted by the ABC.

“He was obviously planted in the audience as a ‘gotcha’ moment.”


“Q&A is a program that’s tilted to the left but when they push the envelope and tilt towards a terrorist recruitment advertisement – that’s just a bridge too far.”

And Queensland LNP Senator James McGrath flat-out called for the programme to be scrapped altogether following the incident.

The frontbench too was having their say on matters, with Prime Minister Tony Abbott apparently telling the Liberal Party Room that the show was a “lefty lynch mob” and that he would be doing something about it.

When questioned about the comments this afternoon during a press conference, Prime Minister Abbott typically dodged ownership of the quote, comparing the Liberal Party Room to a boys weekend in Las Vegas.
“I’m not going to repeat things that were said in the confidentiality of the party room. The party room is a sacred space. What goes in the party room, stays in the party room.”

“What our National Broadcaster has done is give a platform to a convicted criminal and terrorist sympathiser. I believe the National Broadcaster has badly let us down.”

“The ABC needs to have a long, hard look at itself.”

“At some point you need to decide ‘Who’s side are you on?’.”

It’s interesting to note that the Press Conference – which largely focused on the introduction of the Government’s controversial laws that will enable them to strip the citizenship of dual nationals found to be engaged in the loosely defined term “terrorist activities” – took place in front of 10 Australian flags.

Notable because the term “death cult” was indeed used on at least 3 occasions.

And also because of this absolute zinger.

Again, credit where it’s due: Swish.


Photo: Stefan Postles via Getty Images.

via SMH.

More Stuff From PEDESTRIAN.TV