WATCH: Khloe Scoffs A Fish Eye To Dodge The Ultimate O.J. Simpson Question

James Corden has now stumbled across late-night gold twice: Carpool Karaoke is a legitimate pop culture phenomenon, but his Late Late Show segment Spill Your Guts or Fill Your Guts is equally as captivating as Karaoke‘s demented, high-stakes cousin.

Case in point: Khloe Kardashian‘s turn on the show pushed the boundaries of her familial loyalty. After facing the choice of revealing her least favourite Kardashian / Jenner show or chowing down on fish sperm, Corden upped the ante.

He asked whether Khloe believes O.J. Simpson – who was represented in court during his murder trial by Khloe’s dad, Robert – actually committed that beyond-infamous crime. The disembodied eye didn’t stand a chance, there:

Sure, it cut away from her face and we never get to see any chewing, but hey. Props to Corden in this one, too: we imagine it’d take some mettle to burn down a show business bridge in such a dramatic way. Bird saliva, tho…