Gillian Triggs Confirmed George Brandis Wanted Her To Quit The AHRC

Proceedings in Canberra today have ranged from the bizarre to the downright farcical – and the latter was none more evidenced than in an on-going Senate Estimates enquiry into the Human Rights Commission, and more specifically, its President Gillian Triggs.

You might recall a few days ago that Fairfax Media revealed a report that claimed the Attorney General‘s office had attempted to persuade Triggs to resign from her post as President of the commission – a good two weeks before her commission handed down the historically damning Forgotten Children report into the treatment of children held in asylum seeker detention centres. This report was dismissed in its entirety as a partisan stitch up by the Coalition, with Prime Minister Tony Abbott going on the record in radio interviews to state that the commission “should be ashamed of themselves,” that “the most compassionate thing to do is to stop the boats,” and that the Commission should be sending a note of congratulations to former Immigration Minister Scott Morrison that would read, in part, “good job, mate.”
Today, Triggs has appeared in what was at times a very trying, and overall quite extraordinary Senate Estimates hearing, which degenerated quickly from Partisan snipping into a venerable battle of the sexes.
The hearing, chaired by Liberal senator Ian MacDonald, quickly dissolved into frankly unbelievable scenes for what is quite a serious Parliamentary process. Liberal senator Barry O’Sullivan went on the offensive from the beginning, with The Guardian noting that that O’Sullivan “thinks he’s in a Law & Order episode.
First came the questions about the decision making processes of the Human Rights Commission, which Triggs handled reasonably deftly – revealing the approval of a full blown inquiry into children in detention, described as a “10 Year Review” came on the 12th of December, 2013.

I shall try to be as clear as possible. The decision to hold an inquiry was one that evolved gradually over time and reflected many factors; of overarching importance were the high numbers of children held in detention, numbers that fluctuated considerably over many months – other factors were the increasing periods of time for which the children were being held, [and] the forthcoming election in September when information would not be available.

But it’s when questioning turned to the Attorney-General’s apparent attempts to remove Triggs that things got really nutty. Labor senators Jacinta Collins and Penny Wong began the line of questioning, with Triggs confirming that a secretary from the AGD had approached her with the request to resign from her position, with the promise of another opportunity for her being found.

He (the secretary) said he’d been asked to deliver the message from the attorney that he required my resignation. I said what is the reason for this request? I believe he had no details for the basis for it.

I gave him my answer. I have a five year statutory position … which is designed to avoid political interference in the exercise of my tasks.“

“It was definitely said to me that an offer would be made for me to provide work for the government in areas of my expertise in international law.”


Senator Wong asked Triggs if she believed the request to resign and the offer of another position were offered to her in conjunction – a very serious allegation. Triggs confirmed this, stating “There is no doubt in my mind that the two were connected. I thought it was a disgraceful proposal.” However, she stopped short of labelling it an “inducement” – or, in other words, a bribe.

But despite the seriousness of this line of questioning and allegations, the Liberal side of the room – all men – continually guffawed and brayed over the top of the Labor and Greens side of the room, as well as the AHRC –  all women. In fact, at this point Senator O’Sullivan interjected himself over the top of Wong and addressed Senator MacDonald not so much as the chair of a Senate Estimates hearing but as a mate grilling snags at a Saturday piss up.
I thought you might like to hear a man’s voice.

With patience now wearing extremely thin on Triggs, Wong and Greens senator Penny Wright‘s behalf, the gloves began dropping.

First, Triggs, who was left fuming after a question not from Senator O’Sullivan, but from Chair of the hearing Senator MacDonald, who asked why the Commission did nothing prior to this inquiry.
You said we did nothing. This is a profound mis-statement.”

Then Senator Young, who also by this point had had enough.

“There is serious question about your partiality in chairing. I think you are seriously compromising the dignity of the committee. I want to put that on the record.”


And finally, Penny Wong who remarked that MacDonald was turning the inquiry “into a circus.” At which point MacDonald, in passing, made reference to the fact that he simply had not read the Forgotten Children report because of his pre-conceived notice that it was Partisan.

A conclusion he had come to without so much as going beyond the title page.
The year is 2015, and this is how an official, and very serious, Parliamentary proceeding has unfolded.
Dog help us all.
Photo: Bradley Kanaris via Getty Images.

More Stuff From PEDESTRIAN.TV